Home  /  Insights  /  Leadership

Why Leadership Requires More Than Sales Performance

Aurelius Consulting GroupNov 12, 2026 · 4 min read

Almost every sales organization makes the same move sooner or later. Someone keeps beating quota, keeps topping the leaderboard and keeps closing the deals nobody else can. So they get promoted to lead the team. It feels fair and it feels logical. Research suggests it’s also one of the most expensive habits in business.

What the data actually says

The Peter Principle has been a running joke in offices for decades: people get promoted until they land in a job they can’t do. For a long time it was just a joke. Then three economists, Alan Benson (University of Minnesota), Danielle Li (MIT) and Kelly Shue (Yale), tested it on real sales data.

They used data on worker- and manager-level performance for almost 40,000 sales workers across 131 firms. They found that firms systematically promote the best salespeople, even though these workers end up becoming worse managers.

The numbers are specific. Doubling a salesperson’s sales credits raised their chance of promotion by 14.3 percent compared with the baseline. Doubling a new manager’s pre-promotion sales was linked to a 7.5 percent drop in their team’s sales performance.

So the better someone was as a rep, the worse their team did once they became the manager. Most people would expect the opposite.

Why the skills don’t transfer

Selling and leading look alike from the outside. Both involve people, persuasion and pressure. Underneath, they are different jobs. A great salesperson is measured by what they personally achieve. A great leader is measured by what other people achieve because of them.

That shift changes almost everything:

  • From winning to multiplying. Your own close rate stops mattering. Your team’s consistency is what counts.
  • From instinct to explanation. Top performers often can’t say why they’re good. A leader has to turn what they do well into something others can learn.
  • From competing to coaching. The drive that pushes a rep to the top of the leaderboard can work against them when their job is to help the person ranked below them improve.
  • From fast wins to slow builds. A deal closes in days. A strong team takes months of feedback, patience and repetition.

None of this means top salespeople can’t lead. Many do it brilliantly. It means sales numbers don’t tell you whether they can.

The manager shapes the whole team

This matters because the person running a team has a huge effect on it. Gallup finds that managers account for 70% of the variance in team engagement. Engagement in turn tracks with productivity, retention and customer outcomes.

Yet Gallup estimates that organizations choose the wrong person for a manager role 82% of the time. One reason: when Gallup asked U.S. managers why they believed they were hired for their current role, they commonly cited their success in a previous non-managerial role or their tenure in their company or field. In other words, people get promoted for being good at the old job, not for being suited to the new one.

What to look for instead

If sales numbers aren’t the signal, what is? The Benson, Li and Shue study found one useful clue: employees with collaboration experience produce better results as managers. People who already work well inside a team, sharing leads, helping new hires and covering for colleagues, are showing leadership before anyone gives them the title.

Gallup’s research points to a similar set of traits. Strong managers create a culture of clear accountability, build relationships that create trust, open dialogue, and full transparency, and make decisions based on productivity, not politics.

In practice, watch for the person who:

  • other reps go to with questions
  • stays calm and clear when a day goes wrong
  • gives honest feedback without crushing anyone
  • is pleased when a teammate wins, not just when they do
  • can explain why something worked, not just that it did

How to build leaders, not just promote them

1. Separate reward from promotion. The researchers point out that organizations can reward high performers through incentive pay, avoiding the need to use promotions to different roles as an incentive. A great rep who wants to keep selling should be able to grow, earn more and get recognition without being pushed into management.

2. Test leadership before giving the title. Let people train a new hire, lead a small project or run a team for one campaign. You’ll learn more in a few weeks than a year of sales reports can tell you.

3. Use real criteria. Decide what good leadership looks like in your organization, write it down and assess candidates against it.

4. Keep supporting people after the promotion. New managers need coaching, not just a new title. It’s urgent: manager engagement has fallen nine percentage points since 2022, the steepest decline of any worker category, and sits at 22% globally as of 2025.

The bottom line

Strong sales performance proves someone can win. Leadership is about helping other people win, again and again, after you’ve stopped being the one who closes the deal. The companies that grow fastest aren’t the ones that promote their best sellers. They’re the ones that find their best leaders, whether or not those people are at the top of the leaderboard right now, and invest in them.

Written by Aurelius Consulting Group

A human-to-human marketing company in Boston, bringing brands and people together through real, in-person conversations.

Let’s talk

If this approach feels relevant, reach out.

Use the form for general inquiries and our team will respond as soon as we can.